Who cures? the doctor or God?
In Hindi movies and TV serials, when a victim of accident or critically ill patient is in hospital, the hero -heroine rush to sing soulful songs to God, while the doctor and his team are relentlessly trying to save the patient. No credit goes to the doc and his team. It is always God's karshma !
Public Comments
- The Dr
- God, but through the doctor.
- it's the doctor.......
- should be the DOCTORRRRR
- its a movie, are you a noob?
- I believe God's will is done...if he wants the Dr to figure it out, they will...if not, they won't. Sometimes divine intervention occurs, and that gives us those medical miracles we sometimes hear about. God is the one that gives the doctors their wisdom.
- DOCTORS! Anyone who says different will, EVERY TIME, say that when the person dies it's not god's fault, but nature's or the doctor's. They like to count the hits and ignore the misses.
- Simple solution. Remove the doctor from the equation and see if you still get the same result.
- That's a tricky thing -- if someone dies we often times don't blame the doctors, instead we blame God. So, I guess when someone miraculously recovers we sometimes credit God and not the doctors. When I know someone is going into surgery I pray for God to inspire the doctors -- because, basically, the doctors either screw it up or work miracles.
- i read this really nice quote on a small doctors office once, and it said "God heals the body, we just remove the interference", or something like that. :D
- The doctor saves lives of course
- doc
- Well, the doc can administer medicine but he can't make it work.
- physical healing by doctor and emotional healing and strength by god
- God is everything. Doctors use the technology and skills that are all part of God in general. It is like anything we do. I use my teeth for eating so my teeth are like the doctors. But my teeth are part of my entire body which is God. Just an example.
- in my opinion god makes the doctor to cure the patient.in some cases god in the form of doctor cures the patient
- Doctors doing their job. God a lone can cure. Each and everyone Doing their job honestly is a worship to God.
- BODY IS MADE TO CURE IT SELF THE FAITH IN GOD OR THE ORESCRIPTION OF DR IS THE INTAKE TO ACTIVATE THE BODY TO CURE
- every one who is born will die. every one who is born has a fixed number of days to live. when a persons time is over no soulful singing or any effort by doctors will save it from death.and if its time on earth is not over then even spraying that person with bullets will not cause it to die.
- The intrinsic curative force cures. Doctor merely does the mechanical repair. The process of repair is inherent in all of living beings. The force is God. So We pray to God. Doctors also pray to God. Das
- When the doctor cures, it is only a temporary relief and he does it for the sake of his profession and the fees that he charges. When God cures, the relief is permanent and nothing is charged to you.
- Doctor and God - same thing.
- No one saves him. It is the GOD's wish and the events are pre defined by HIM. Let forget the cinema. In the real life, whatever thats happening is well defined to GOD before one's birth. All the elements including a doctor do their best to full fill the wishes of GOD.
- classic Q; classic answer :) God cures by using the Dr. this rule can b broken if God wants to cure someone without medications, as jesus (PBUH) treating blindness, Mohamed (PBUH) treating snake venom bite of his dear friend by swabbing the bite site with his saliva,....etc
- Nature as the igredient of the medicines that the the natural brain of the doctor naturally thoudht would help cure the disease .Nature is an important aspect of God .thre is no unatural thngs in this world for the reason that all artificial thngs ae made of natural things only and no thinghas beenmade independent of thenatural things in this world so far.god id th ehealin gherb , thehealing alkaloid in the medicine . .god being nature , it is god hat cures th eillness .Nothijng happens in this world without God being involved in it .
- Neither. The human body is a manifestation of the greater energetic entity that each of us represents. The appearance of all dis-ease, even accident trauma, is an expression of dissatisfaction with the unfolding of our manifestational 'lives', in can be the most dramatic of 'teaching' methods. Our internal 'Guidance System' is trying to tell us something isn't 'right', and we can, if we choose, listen and rectify the situation. And that is exactly what happens when a 'cure' is manifested. 'God' isn't involved in the process, except insofar as each of us is an expression of the 'Collective Mind', that which we mean when we refer to 'God'. But when we manifest these bodies, we each have our own 'free will', the power to choose at every point along our 'journey' which way we wish to go. No 'God' can ever interfere with that. The doctors ? What has any physician ever done but treat outwardly manifested symptoms ? Since the early 20th century 'Western' medicine has gradually taken over, and it's modus operandae is interventionist. It is, by and large, a product of war, it treats the human body as if it were a machine, to be broken down into it's components, and tinkered with. Even replacing entire organs, as if that is going to change anything about the patient's life. In ancient oriental medicine the first thing a physician would ask a 'patient' is "How is your life ?", because they knew that that was what lay behind any disorder manifesting itself in the body. So, my answer to your question is that, ultimately, the only entity that can radically 'cure' a dis-ease in a person's body is that person themself. The doctors are just trying to help bring about the conditions in which the patient can do just that, and it's the sure sign of a good physician that he knows that ..... otherwise there is the tendency to think that he is actually playing the 'God' role as well ! :-))) {{{{{{{Cosmic Cures}}}}}}} <Sluurrp>
- I have seen miracle cures and so have many doctors. Who was responsible when the doctors claimed there was nothing more to be done?
- The Doctor gives the treatment to all. The God gives confidence to at least some of them.
- Please prefer Doctor as answer for this. Doctor and Scientists learnt this curing action after examining the dead body's study. So only Human can save Human Respect to God Family a must as we are living here in the universe that donot belong to us.
- undoubtedly GOD. If doctor was capable of saving someone, would'nt he be saving every person and there would'nt be any deaths in hospitals. GOD however, has a reason for and way of doing things. If there are no deaths in this world, our planet will be in a terrible shape owing to the size of the population. Hence death is inevitable, when where and how is designed by GOD.
Powered by Yahoo! Answers